70th OREGON LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY--1999 Regular Session
Enrolled
House Bill 2494
Sponsored by Representatives STARR, SNODGRASS, LOWE, PIERCY,
PROZANSKI, BOWMAN, Senator BROWN; Representatives JENSON,
KNOPP, KRUMMEL, MINNIS, RASMUSSEN, SCHRADER, Senators BURDICK,
QUTUB, SHANNON, STARR
CHAPTER ................
AN ACT
Relating to spiritual treatment; amending ORS 137.712, 163.125,
163.206, 163.555 and 419B.005; and providing for criminal
sentence reduction that requires approval by a two-thirds
majority.
Be It Enacted by the People of the State of Oregon:
SECTION 1. ORS 163.125 is amended to read:
163.125. (1) Criminal homicide constitutes manslaughter in the
second degree when:
(a) It is committed recklessly;
(b) A person intentionally causes or aids another person to
commit suicide; or
(c) A person, with criminal negligence, causes the death of a
child under 14 years of age or a dependent person, as defined in
ORS 163.205, and:
(A) The person has previously engaged in a pattern or practice
of assault or torture of the victim or another child under 14
years of age or a dependent person; or
(B) The person causes the death by neglect or maltreatment, as
defined in ORS 163.115.
(2) Manslaughter in the second degree is a Class B felony.
{ - (3) It is an affirmative defense to a charge of violating
subsection (1)(c)(B) of this section that the child or dependent
person was under care or treatment solely by spiritual means
pursuant to the religious beliefs or practices of the child or
person or the parent or guardian of the child or person. - }
SECTION 2. ORS 137.712 is amended to read:
137.712. (1)(a) Notwithstanding ORS 137.700 and 137.707, when a
person is convicted of { + manslaughter in the second degree as
defined in ORS 163.125, + } assault in the second degree as
defined in ORS 163.175 (1)(b), kidnapping in the second degree as
defined in ORS 163.225 or robbery in the second degree as defined
in ORS 164.405, the court may impose a sentence according to the
rules of the Oregon Criminal Justice Commission that is less than
the minimum sentence that otherwise may be required by ORS
137.700 or 137.707 if the court, on the record at sentencing,
makes the findings set forth in subsection (2) of this section
and finds that a substantial and compelling reason under the
rules of the Oregon Criminal Justice Commission justifies the
lesser sentence. When the court imposes a sentence under this
Enrolled House Bill 2494 (HB 2494-BCCA) Page 1
subsection, the person is eligible for a reduction in the
sentence as provided in ORS 421.121 and any other statute.
(b) In order to make a dispositional departure under this
section, the court must make the following additional findings on
the record:
(A) There exists a substantial and compelling reason not relied
upon in paragraph (a) of this subsection;
(B) A sentence of probation will be more effective than a
prison term in reducing the risk of offender recidivism; and
(C) A sentence of probation will better serve to protect
society.
(2) A conviction is subject to subsection (1) of this section
only if the sentencing court finds on the record by a
preponderance of the evidence:
{ + (a) If the conviction is for manslaughter in the second
degree:
(A) That the defendant is the mother or father of the victim;
(B) That the death of the victim was the result of an injury or
illness that was not caused by the defendant;
(C) That the defendant treated the injury or illness solely by
spiritual treatment in accordance with the religious beliefs or
practices of the defendant and based on a good faith belief that
spiritual treatment would bring about the victim's recovery from
the injury or illness;
(D) That no other person previously under the defendant's care
has died or sustained significant physical injury as a result of
or despite the use of spiritual treatment, regardless of whether
the spiritual treatment was used alone or in conjunction with
medical care; and
(E) That the defendant does not have a previous conviction for
a crime listed in subsection (4) of this section or for criminal
mistreatment in the second degree. + }
{ - (a) - } { + (b) + } If the conviction is for assault in
the second degree:
(A) That the victim was not physically injured by means of a
deadly weapon;
(B) That the victim did not suffer a significant physical
injury; and
(C) That the defendant does not have a previous conviction for
a crime listed in subsection (4) of this section.
{ - (b) - } { + (c) + } If the conviction is for kidnapping
in the second degree:
(A) That the victim was at least 12 years of age at the time
the crime was committed; and
(B) That the defendant does not have a previous conviction for
a crime listed in subsection (4) of this section.
{ - (c) - } { + (d) + } If the conviction is for robbery in
the second degree:
(A) That the victim did not suffer a significant physical
injury;
(B) That, if the defendant represented by words or conduct that
the defendant was armed with a dangerous weapon, the
representation did not reasonably put the victim in fear of
imminent significant physical injury;
(C) That, if the defendant represented by words or conduct that
the defendant was armed with a deadly weapon, the representation
did not reasonably put the victim in fear of imminent physical
injury; and
(D) That the defendant does not have a previous conviction for
a crime listed in subsection (4) of this section.
Enrolled House Bill 2494 (HB 2494-BCCA) Page 2
(3) In making the findings required by subsections (1) and (2)
of this section, the court may consider any evidence presented at
trial and may receive and consider any additional relevant
information offered by either party at sentencing.
(4) The crimes to which subsection { - (2)(a)(C), (b)(B) and
(c)(D) - } { + (2)(a)(E), (b)(C), (c)(B) and (d)(D) + } of this
section refer are:
(a) A crime listed in ORS 137.700 (2) or 137.707 (4);
(b) Escape in the first degree, as defined in ORS 162.165;
(c) Aggravated murder, as defined in ORS 163.095;
(d) Criminally negligent homicide, as defined in ORS 163.145;
(e) Assault in the third degree, as defined in ORS 163.165;
(f) Criminal mistreatment in the first degree, as defined in
ORS 163.205 (1)(b)(A);
(g) Rape in the third degree, as defined in ORS 163.355;
(h) Sodomy in the third degree, as defined in ORS 163.385;
(i) Sexual abuse in the second degree, as defined in ORS
163.425;
(j) Stalking, as defined in ORS 163.732;
(k) Burglary in the first degree, as defined in ORS 164.225,
when it is classified as a person felony under the rules of the
Oregon Criminal Justice Commission;
(L) Arson in the first degree, as defined in ORS 164.325;
(m) Robbery in the third degree, as defined in ORS 164.395;
(n) Intimidation in the first degree, as defined in ORS
166.165;
(o) Promoting prostitution, as defined in ORS 167.012; and
(p) An attempt or solicitation to commit any Class A or B
felony listed in paragraphs (a) to (L) of this subsection.
(5) Notwithstanding ORS 137.550 (4)(b), if a person sentenced
to probation under this section violates a condition of probation
by committing a new crime, the court shall revoke the probation
and impose the presumptive sentence of imprisonment under the
rules of the Oregon Criminal Justice Commission.
(6) As used in this section:
(a) 'Conviction' includes, but is not limited to:
(A) A juvenile court adjudication finding a person within the
court's jurisdiction under ORS 419C.005, if the person was at
least 15 years of age at the time the person committed the
offense that brought the person within the jurisdiction of the
juvenile court.
(B) A conviction in another jurisdiction for a crime that if
committed in this state would constitute a crime listed in
subsection (4) of this section.
(b) 'Previous conviction' means a conviction that was entered
prior to imposing sentence on the current crime provided that the
prior conviction is based on a crime committed in a separate
criminal episode. 'Previous conviction' does not include a
conviction for a Class C felony, including an attempt or
solicitation to commit a Class B felony, or a misdemeanor, unless
the conviction was entered within the 10-year period immediately
preceding the date on which the current crime was committed.
(c) 'Significant physical injury' means a physical injury that:
(A) Creates a risk of death that is not a remote risk;
(B) Causes a serious and temporary disfigurement;
(C) Causes a protracted disfigurement; or
(D) Causes a prolonged impairment of health or the function of
any bodily organ.
SECTION 3. ORS 163.555 is amended to read:
Enrolled House Bill 2494 (HB 2494-BCCA) Page 3
163.555. (1) A person commits the crime of criminal nonsupport
if, being the parent, lawful guardian or other person lawfully
charged with the support of a child under 18 years of age, born
in or out of wedlock, the person refuses or neglects without
lawful excuse to provide support for such child.
(2) { - (a) - } It is no defense to a prosecution under this
section that either parent has contracted a subsequent marriage,
that issue has been born of a subsequent marriage, that the
defendant is the parent of issue born of a prior marriage or that
the child is being supported by another person or agency.
{ - (b) In a prosecution for failing to provide necessary and
proper medical attention, it is a defense that the medical
attention was provided by treatment by prayer through spiritual
means alone by adherents of a bona fide religious denomination
that relies exclusively on this form of treatment in lieu of
medical attention. Nothing in this subsection shall affect the
jurisdiction of the juvenile court in proceedings instituted
under ORS chapter 419B or 419C. - }
(3) Criminal nonsupport is a Class C felony.
SECTION 4. ORS 419B.005 is amended to read:
419B.005. As used in ORS 418.747, 418.748, 418.749 and 419B.005
to 419B.050, unless the context requires otherwise:
(1)(a) 'Abuse' means:
(A) Any assault, as defined in ORS chapter 163, of a child and
any physical injury to a child which has been caused by other
than accidental means, including any injury which appears to be
at variance with the explanation given of the injury.
(B) Any mental injury to a child, which shall include only
observable and substantial impairment of the child's mental or
psychological ability to function caused by cruelty to the child,
with due regard to the culture of the child.
(C) Rape of a child, which includes but is not limited to rape,
sodomy, unlawful sexual penetration and incest, as those acts are
defined in ORS chapter 163.
(D) Sexual abuse, as defined in ORS chapter 163.
(E) Sexual exploitation, including but not limited to:
(i) Contributing to the sexual delinquency of a minor, as
defined in ORS chapter 163, and any other conduct which allows,
employs, authorizes, permits, induces or encourages a child to
engage in the performing for people to observe or the
photographing, filming, tape recording or other exhibition which,
in whole or in part, depicts sexual conduct or contact, as
defined in ORS 167.002 or described in ORS 163.665 and 163.670,
sexual abuse involving a child or rape of a child, but not
including any conduct which is part of any investigation
conducted pursuant to ORS 419B.020 or which is designed to serve
educational or other legitimate purposes; and
(ii) Allowing, permitting, encouraging or hiring a child to
engage in prostitution, as defined in ORS chapter 167.
(F) Negligent treatment or maltreatment of a child, including
but not limited to the failure to provide adequate food,
clothing, shelter or medical care { + that is likely to endanger
the health or welfare of the child + }. { - However, any child
who is under care or treatment solely by spiritual means pursuant
to the religious beliefs or practices of the child or the child's
parent or guardian shall not, for this reason alone, be
considered a neglected or maltreated child under this
section. - }
(G) Threatened harm to a child, which means subjecting a child
to a substantial risk of harm to the child's health or welfare.
Enrolled House Bill 2494 (HB 2494-BCCA) Page 4
(H) Buying or selling a person under 18 years of age as
described in ORS 163.537.
(b) 'Abuse' does not include reasonable discipline unless the
discipline results in one of the conditions described in
paragraph (a) of this subsection.
(2) 'Child' means an unmarried person who is under 18 years of
age.
(3) 'Public or private official' means:
(a) Physician, including any intern or resident.
(b) Dentist.
(c) School employee.
(d) Licensed practical nurse or registered nurse.
(e) Employee of the Department of Human Resources, State
Commission on Children and Families, Child Care Division of the
Employment Department, the Oregon Youth Authority, a county
health department, a community mental health and developmental
disabilities program, a county juvenile department, a licensed
child-caring agency or an alcohol and drug treatment program.
(f) Peace officer.
(g) Psychologist.
(h) Clergyman.
(i) Licensed clinical social worker.
(j) Optometrist.
(k) Chiropractor.
(L) Certified provider of child care or foster care, or an
employee thereof.
(m) Attorney.
(n) Naturopathic physician.
(o) Licensed professional counselor.
(p) Licensed marriage and family therapist.
(q) Firefighter or emergency medical technician.
(r) A court appointed special advocate, as defined in ORS
419A.004.
(4) 'Law enforcement agency' means:
(a) Any city or municipal police department.
(b) Any county sheriff's office.
(c) The Oregon State Police.
(d) A county juvenile department.
SECTION 5. ORS 163.206 is amended to read:
163.206. ORS 163.200 and 163.205 do not apply:
(1) To a person acting pursuant to a court order, an advance
directive or a power of attorney for health care pursuant to ORS
127.505 to 127.660;
(2) To a person withholding or withdrawing life-sustaining
procedures or artificially administered nutrition and hydration
pursuant to ORS 127.505 to 127.660;
(3) When a competent person refuses food, physical care or
medical care;
(4) To a person who provides an elderly { + person + } or
{ + a + } dependent person { + who is at least 15 years of
age + } with spiritual treatment through prayer from a duly
accredited practitioner of spiritual treatment as provided in ORS
124.095, in lieu of medical treatment, in accordance with the
tenets and practices of a recognized church or religious
denomination of which the elderly { + or dependent + } person
{ - or the parent or guardian of the dependent person - } is a
member or an adherent; or
(5) To a duly accredited practitioner of spiritual treatment as
provided in ORS 124.095.
----------
Enrolled House Bill 2494 (HB 2494-BCCA) Page 5
Passed by House May 13, 1999
Repassed by House July 21, 1999
...........................................................
Chief Clerk of House
...........................................................
Speaker of House
Passed by Senate July 12, 1999
Repassed by Senate July 22, 1999
...........................................................
President of Senate
Enrolled House Bill 2494 (HB 2494-BCCA) Page 6
Received by Governor:
......M.,............., 1999
Approved:
......M.,............., 1999
...........................................................
Governor
Filed in Office of Secretary of State:
......M.,............., 1999
...........................................................
Secretary of State
Enrolled House Bill 2494 (HB 2494-BCCA) Page 7